| 1 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 2 | Matt Ryan | Atlanta Falcons | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 3 | Patrick Mahomes II | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /15Emerald /2Sapphire /5 |
| 4 | Courtland Sutton | Denver Broncos | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 5 | Dan Marino | Miami Dolphins | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 8 | Kirk Cousins | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 12 | Tom Brady | New England Patriots | numbered /5Emerald /2 |
| 14 | Josh Allen | Buffalo Bills | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 15 | Emmitt Smith | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /10Emerald /2Silver /5 |
| 16 | Peyton Manning | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /5 |
| 17 | Brett Favre | Green Bay Packers | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 19 | John Elway | Denver Broncos | numbered /10Emerald /2Silver /5 |
| 20 | Edgerrin James | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 21 | Archie Manning | New Orleans Saints | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 23 | Tyreek Hill | Kansas City Chiefs | No base version; parallels onlyEmerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 24 | Ben Roethlisberger | Pittsburgh Steelers | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 25 | Calvin Ridley | Atlanta Falcons | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 26 | Joe Montana | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /10Emerald /2Silver /5 |
| 27 | Matthew Stafford | Detroit Lions | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 28 | Keenan Allen | Los Angeles Chargers | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 29 | Sony Michel | New England Patriots | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 30 | Luke Kuechly | Carolina Panthers | No base version; parallels onlyEmerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5 |
| 31 | Sam Darnold | New York Jets | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5 |
| 33 | Ricky Williams | Miami Dolphins | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 35 | Adrian Peterson | Washington Redskins | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 36 | Bradley Chubb | Denver Broncos | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 37 | Amari Cooper | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 40 | Leighton Vander Esch | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 41 | Adam Thielen | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Silver /10 |
| 42 | Kerryon Johnson | Detroit Lions | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 43 | Mark Duper | Miami Dolphins | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 44 | Warren Moon | Houston Oilers | No base version; parallels onlyEmerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3Silver /10 |
| 45 | Mitchell Trubisky | Chicago Bears | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 46 | Barry Sanders | Detroit Lions | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 47 | Leonard Fournette | Jacksonville Jaguars | numbered /15Emerald /2Sapphire /5 |
| 48 | Randall Cunningham | Philadelphia Eagles | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 49 | Nick Chubb | Cleveland Browns | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 50 | Derek Carr | Oakland Raiders | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3Silver /10 |
| 51 | Ed Reed | New York Jets | numbered /10Emerald /2Ruby /5 |
| 52 | Julius Peppers | Carolina Panthers | numbered /15Emerald /2Sapphire /5 |
| 53 | Rob Gronkowski | New England Patriots | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Silver /10 |
| 54 | Marcus Mariota | Tennessee Titans | No base version; parallels onlyEmerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3Silver /8 |
| 55 | Marquez Valdes-Scantling | Green Bay Packers | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 56 | Philip Rivers | Los Angeles Chargers | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 57 | Derrick Brooks | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10 |
| 59 | Tony Dorsett | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 60 | Harrison Smith | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 61 | Kenny Golladay | Detroit Lions | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 62 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 63 | Steve Young | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Silver /10 |
| 64 | Reggie Wayne | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3Silver /10 |
| 65 | Jameis Winston | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 66 | Andre Johnson | Houston Texans | No base version; parallels onlyEmerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10 |
| 67 | Clay Matthews | Los Angeles Rams | numbered /25Emerald /5Ruby /15Sapphire /10Silver /20 |
| 70 | Carson Wentz | Philadelphia Eagles | numbered /15Emerald /2Ruby /5Sapphire /3 |
| 71 | Jerry Rice | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /10Emerald /2Sapphire /3Silver /5 |
| 72 | Fred Taylor | Jacksonville Jaguars | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 74 | A.J. Green | Cincinnati Bengals | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |
| 75 | Mike Williams | Los Angeles Chargers | numbered /20Emerald /3Ruby /10Sapphire /5Silver /15 |