| 1 | Drew Brees | New Orleans Saints | Autonumbered /10Gold /5 |
| 2 | Dak Prescott | Dallas Cowboys | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5 |
| 3 | Tony Gonzalez | Kansas City Chiefs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 4 | Bruce Smith | Buffalo Bills | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 5 | Ted Hendricks | Oakland Raiders | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 6 | Hines Ward | Pittsburgh Steelers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 7 | Lawrence Taylor | New York Giants | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 8 | Tim Brown | Oakland Raiders | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 9 | Warren Moon | Houston Oilers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 11 | Patrick Mahomes II | Kansas City Chiefs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 12 | Tedy Bruschi | New England Patriots | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 13 | Steve Largent | Seattle Seahawks | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 15 | Devonta Freeman | Atlanta Falcons | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 16 | Mike Evans | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 17 | Tyreek Hill | Kansas City Chiefs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 18 | Deion Branch | New England Patriots | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 19 | Greg Olsen | Carolina Panthers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 20 | Bob Lilly | Dallas Cowboys | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 21 | Aaron Donald | Los Angeles Rams | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 23 | Lamar Miller | Houston Texans | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 24 | Travis Kelce | Kansas City Chiefs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 25 | Sterling Sharpe | Green Bay Packers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 26 | Devin Funchess | Carolina Panthers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 27 | Marvin Jones Jr. | Detroit Lions | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 28 | Jeremy Shockey | New York Giants | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 30 | Ozzie Newsome | Cleveland Browns | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 32 | Fletcher Cox | Philadelphia Eagles | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 34 | Jermaine Kearse | New York Jets | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 35 | Joe Mixon | Cincinnati Bengals | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 36 | JuJu Smith-Schuster | Pittsburgh Steelers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 37 | Jerick McKinnon | San Francisco 49ers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 40 | Harry Carson | New York Giants | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 41 | Ken Anderson | Cincinnati Bengals | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 42 | Mark Gastineau | New York Jets | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 43 | Trent Dilfer | Baltimore Ravens | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 44 | Marshon Lattimore | New Orleans Saints | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 45 | Willis McGahee | Baltimore Ravens | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 46 | O.J. Howard | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 47 | Melvin Ingram | Los Angeles Chargers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 48 | Drew Pearson | Dallas Cowboys | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 49 | Geno Atkins | Cincinnati Bengals | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 50 | Tom Rathman | San Francisco 49ers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 51 | Charles Haley | San Francisco 49ers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 53 | Vinny Testaverde | New York Jets | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 54 | Danny White | Dallas Cowboys | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 55 | Isaac Bruce | St. Louis Rams | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 56 | Len Dawson | Kansas City Chiefs | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 57 | Rodney Harrison | San Diego Chargers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /10 |
| 58 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 59 | LeRoy Butler | Green Bay Packers | Autonumbered /50Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /25 |
| 60 | Tom Brady | New England Patriots | Autonumbered /10Gold /5 |