| 1 | Bernie Williams | New York Yankees | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 2 | Terry Francona | Cleveland Indians | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 3 | Yoenis Cespedes | New York Mets | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 5 | Cody Bellinger | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 6 | Joe Carter | Toronto Blue Jays | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 7 | Anthony Rizzo | Chicago Cubs | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /7 |
| 8 | Roger Clemens | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /7Emerald /3Gold /5 |
| 9 | Josh Donaldson | Toronto Blue Jays | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 10 | Chris Sale | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 11 | Addison Russell | Chicago Cubs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 13 | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 14 | Carlos Martinez | St. Louis Cardinals | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 15 | Alan Trammell | Detroit Tigers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 16 | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 17 | Nolan Arenado | Colorado Rockies | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 18 | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 19 | Edwin Encarnacion | Cleveland Indians | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 20 | George Springer | Houston Astros | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 21 | Shohei Ohtani | Los Angeles Angels | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 22 | Dustin Pedroia | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 23 | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autonumbered /10Emerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 24 | David Ross | Chicago Cubs | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 25 | Charlie Blackmon | Colorado Rockies | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 26 | Manny Machado | Baltimore Orioles | Autonumbered /15Emerald /3Gold /5Ruby /10Sapphire /7 |
| 28 | José Ramírez | Cleveland Indians | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 32 | AJ Hinch | Houston Astros | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 34 | Trea Turner | Washington Nationals | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 36 | Yu Darvish | Los Angeles Dodgers | AutoNo base version; parallels onlyEmerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 37 | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 38 | Masahiro Tanaka | New York Yankees | AutoNo base version; parallels onlyEmerald /3Gold /5Sapphire /7 |
| 41 | Keith Hernandez | New York Mets | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 42 | Jose Canseco | Oakland Athletics | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 44 | Omar Vizquel | Cleveland Indians | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 45 | Andres Galarraga | Montréal Expos | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 46 | Ted Simmons | St. Louis Cardinals | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 47 | Clayton Kershaw | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 49 | Willie McGee | St. Louis Cardinals | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 50 | Edgar Martinez | Seattle Mariners | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 51 | Andy Pettitte | New York Yankees | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 52 | Pete Rose | Cincinnati Reds | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 54 | Darryl Strawberry | New York Mets | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 55 | Nomar Mazara | Texas Rangers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 57 | Dennis Eckersley | Oakland Athletics | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 59 | Eric Thames | Milwaukee Brewers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 60 | Gleyber Torres | New York Yankees | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 61 | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 65 | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 66 | Alan Trammell | Detroit Tigers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 68 | Andrew Benintendi | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 69 | Brandon Belt | San Francisco Giants | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 71 | Estevan Florial | New York Yankees | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 73 | Gaylord Perry | San Francisco Giants | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 74 | Corey Kluber | Cleveland Indians | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 75 | Jim Rice | Boston Red Sox | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 78 | Adrian Gonzalez | New York Mets | AutoNo base version; parallels onlyRuby /20 |
| 79 | Carlos Gonzalez | Colorado Rockies | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Sapphire /15 |
| 80 | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | AutoNo base version; parallels onlyRuby /20 |
| 81 | José Berríos | Minnesota Twins | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 82 | Bo Bichette | Toronto Blue Jays | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |
| 83 | Justin Turner | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autonumbered /25Emerald /5Gold /10Ruby /20Sapphire /15 |