| 1 | Patrick Mahomes IILen Dawson | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /5 |
| 2 | Kurt WarnerJared Goff | St. Louis RamsLos Angeles Rams | numbered /5 |
| 3 | Jim KellyJosh Allen | Buffalo Bills | numbered /5 |
| 4 | Mike SingletaryRoquan Smith | Chicago Bears | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 5 | Dan MarinoJosh Rosen | Miami Dolphins | numbered /5 |
| 6 | Travis KelceJason Kelce | Kansas City ChiefsPhiladelphia Eagles | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 7 | Warren MoonDeshaun Watson | Houston OilersHouston Texans | numbered /5 |
| 8 | Michael VickLamar Jackson | Atlanta FalconsBaltimore Ravens | numbered /10 |
| 9 | Barry SandersBilly Sims | Detroit Lions | numbered /5 |
| 10 | Willie GaultAnthony Miller | Chicago Bears | numbered /15Gold /10 |
| 11 | Phillip LindsayTerrell Davis | Denver Broncos | numbered /5 |
| 12 | Khalil MackJulius Peppers | Chicago Bears | numbered /5 |
| 13 | Randy WhiteLeighton Vander Esch | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 14 | Baker MayfieldBernie Kosar | Cleveland Browns | numbered /5 |
| 15 | Jameis WinstonDoug Williams | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | numbered /5 |
| 16 | Mike GolicBob Golic | Philadelphia EaglesCleveland Browns | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 17 | Jack DoyleDallas Clark | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 18 | John KuhnAaron Ripkowski | Green Bay Packers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 19 | Andre RisonCalvin Ridley | Atlanta Falcons | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 20 | LaVar ArringtonRyan Kerrigan | Washington Redskins | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 21 | Stephen GostkowskiAdam Vinatieri | New England Patriots | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 22 | Ricky WilliamsRonnie Brown | Miami Dolphins | numbered /10 |
| 23 | Charles HaleyPatrick Willis | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /15 |
| 24 | Tiki BarberSaquon Barkley | New York Giants | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 25 | Greg OlsenWesley Walls | Carolina Panthers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 26 | Marcus DavenportRickey Jackson | New Orleans Saints | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 27 | Ahman GreenAaron Jones | Green Bay Packers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 28 | Quenton NelsonJeff Saturday | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 29 | Joe MixonIckey Woods | Cincinnati Bengals | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 30 | Amari CooperMichael Irvin | Dallas Cowboys | numbered /5 |
| 31 | Antonio GatesKellen Winslow | Los Angeles ChargersSan Diego Chargers | numbered /10 |
| 32 | Warren SappClelin Ferrell | Oakland Raiders | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 33 | Tony SiragusaHaloti Ngata | Baltimore Ravens | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 34 | Demaryius ThomasCourtland Sutton | Denver Broncos | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 35 | Neil SmithChris Jones | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 36 | Tony GonzalezTravis Kelce | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /5 |
| 37 | Darius LeonardDwight Freeney | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 38 | Derrick BrooksDevin White | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 39 | Noah FantJulius Thomas | Denver Broncos | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 40 | Carl EllerLinval Joseph | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 41 | Jeffery SimmonsJevon Kearse | Tennessee Titans | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 42 | Brent JonesGeorge Kittle | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 43 | Ryan ShazierT.J. Watt | Pittsburgh Steelers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 44 | Rashan GaryGilbert Brown | Green Bay Packers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 45 | Ty LawStephon Gilmore | New England Patriots | numbered /10 |
| 46 | Harrison SmithPaul Krause | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /10 |
| 47 | Marshawn LynchShaun Alexander | Seattle Seahawks | numbered /5 |
| 48 | Frank GoreRoger Craig | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /10 |
| 49 | Anquan BoldinMiles Boykin | Baltimore Ravens | numbered /15 |
| 50 | James ConnerBenny Snell Jr. | Pittsburgh Steelers | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 51 | Philip RiversEaston Stick | Los Angeles Chargers | numbered /5 |
| 52 | Drew BledsoeJarrett Stidham | New England Patriots | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 53 | Dalvin CookAlexander Mattison | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 54 | Damien HarrisSony Michel | New England Patriots | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 55 | Tarik CohenDevin Hester | Chicago Bears | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 56 | LeSean McCoyDevin Singletary | Buffalo Bills | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 57 | Joe MontanaSteve Young | San Francisco 49ers | numbered /5Gold /3 |
| 58 | Andy IsabellaChristian Kirk | Arizona Cardinals | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 59 | Kyle RudolphIrv Smith Jr. | Minnesota Vikings | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 60 | T.Y. HiltonParris Campbell | Indianapolis Colts | numbered /10 |
| 61 | J.J. Arcega-WhitesideDeSean Jackson | Philadelphia Eagles | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 62 | Tyreek HillMecole Hardman Jr. | Kansas City Chiefs | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 63 | Miles SandersBrian Westbrook | Philadelphia Eagles | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 64 | John ElwayDrew Lock | Denver Broncos | numbered /5 |
| 65 | N'Keal HarryTroy Brown | New England Patriots | numbered /10Gold /5 |
| 66 | Kenny GolladayHerman Moore | Detroit Lions | numbered /15Gold /5 |
| 67 | Marshawn LynchJosh Jacobs | Oakland Raiders | numbered /5 |
| 68 | Dwayne HaskinsJoe Theismann | Washington Redskins | numbered /10 |
| 69 | Eli ManningDaniel Jones | New York Giants | numbered /5 |
| 70 | Kyler MurrayCarson Palmer | Arizona Cardinals | numbered /5 |