| 1 | Tris Speaker | Cleveland Indians | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 2 | Tim Raines | Montréal Expos | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 3 | Gary Carter | New York Mets | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 4 | Pedro Martinez | Boston Red Sox | numbered /99Button /2Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /5 |
| 5 | Tommy Lasorda | Los Angeles Dodgers | numbered /99Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /4 |
| 6 | Al Kaline | Detroit Tigers | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 7 | Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 8 | Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | numbered /99Button /4Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 9 | Larry Walker | Colorado Rockies | numbered /99Button /5Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /3 |
| 10 | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 11 | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 12 | Luis Aparicio | Baltimore Orioles | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 13 | Roberto Clemente | Pittsburgh Pirates | numbered /21Holo Gold /10Holo Silver /5 |
| 14 | Cal Ripken | Baltimore Orioles | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 15 | Ken Griffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners | numbered /99Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 16 | Herb Pennock | Boston Red Sox | numbered /49Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 17 | Wade Boggs | Boston Red Sox | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 18 | Richie Ashburn | Philadelphia Phillies | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 19 | Eddie Murray | Baltimore Orioles | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 20 | Don Drysdale | Los Angeles Dodgers | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 21 | Nolan Ryan | New York Mets | numbered /30Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 22 | Don Sutton | California Angels | numbered /5Holo Gold /3 |
| 23 | Rickey Henderson | Oakland Athletics | numbered /99Button /6Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 24 | Ivan Rodriguez | Texas Rangers | numbered /99Button /4Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /3 |
| 25 | Jim Thome | Philadelphia Phillies | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 26 | Bobby Doerr | Boston Red Sox | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 27 | Joe Morgan | Cincinnati Reds | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 28 | Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 29 | Larry Doby | Cleveland Indians | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 30 | Orlando Cepeda | San Francisco Giants | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 31 | George Brett | Kansas City Royals | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /5 |
| 32 | Mike Piazza | Los Angeles Dodgers | numbered /49Button /3Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 33 | Duke Snider | Brooklyn Dodgers | numbered /99Button /5Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 34 | Craig Biggio | Houston Astros | numbered /99Button /4Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /7 |
| 35 | Bill Mazeroski | Pittsburgh Pirates | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 36 | Joe Torre | New York Yankees | numbered /99Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /5 |
| 37 | Vladimir Guerrero | Anaheim Angels | numbered /25 |
| 38 | Harold Baines | Chicago White Sox | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /5 |
| 39 | Fergie Jenkins | Chicago Cubs | numbered /99Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /5 |
| 40 | Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | numbered /99Button /1Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /3 |
| 41 | Alan Trammell | Detroit Tigers | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 42 | Mel Ott | New York Giants | numbered /25Button /1Holo Gold /10Holo Silver /4 |
| 43 | Bill Dickey | New York Yankees | numbered /49Holo Gold /8Holo Silver /8 |
| 44 | Kirby Puckett | Minnesota Twins | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 45 | Jack Morris | Detroit Tigers | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /3 |
| 46 | Ozzie Smith | San Diego Padres | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 47 | Billy Williams | Chicago Cubs | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 48 | Jeff Bagwell | Houston Astros | numbered /99Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 49 | Lou Brock | St. Louis Cardinals | numbered /49Holo Gold /25Holo Silver /10 |
| 50 | Mickey Mantle | New York Yankees | numbered /25Button /2Holo Gold /10Holo Silver /7 |